Vanity Karma

How is living even worth it? Wisdom from Ecclesiastes and the Bhagavad-gita

  • The Book
    • What It’s About
    • Publication Details
    • Contents
    • About the Publisher
  • The Author
    • About the Author
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Reviews
  • Press Kit
    • About Jayadvaita Swami
    • About Vanity Karma
    • Interview Questions & Pronunciation
    • Photos
  • Resources
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Images
    • Ecclesiastes
    • Krishna Spirituality
  • Contact
  • Press releases

Home » Resources » Ecclesiastes » FAQ

FAQ


What is Ecclesiastes?

It’s a book of the Bible. It’s found in the Old Testament, or what Jews might prefer to call the Hebrew Scriptures.


How big is the book?

Twelve chapters, or 220 verses.


Who wrote it?

No one knows. The main speaker of the book is someone called Qohelet. His words are framed by a narrator who gives a brief introduction and a short epilogue.

At the start of the book, the narrator identifies Qohelet as “the son of David” and “king in Jersualem.” This could only be King Solomon, and according to tradition Qohelet is indeed Solomon. Modern scholars, however, generally regard this Solomonic authorship as a literary fiction.


Do we know anything more about this person Qohelet?

What the narrator says about Qohelet in the epilogue is sparse: “Qohelet was wise and he also taught the people knowledge. Having listened and deliberated, he set in order many proverbs. Qohelet sought to find pleasing words, and he wrote words of truth honestly.” (Eccl. 12:8-10)

Qohelet is mentioned nowhere else in the Bible. Even the word itself appears only in this one book.

What matters most about Qohelet is what he says.


Does the name “Qohelet” mean something?

The name “Qohelet” is generally held to come from a Hebrew root meaning “to assemble” or “to gather.” And so “Qohelet” is often thought of as a leader of an assembly. Translators have called him “the Speaker,” “the Teacher,” “the Philosopher,” “the Debater,” “the Preacher,” and so on. The list of choices is long.


What does “Ecclesiastes” mean?

It means “Qohelet.” In Greek, an “ekklesia” was an assembly. So the translators who put the Hebrew scriptures into Greek some two thousand or more years ago (for the benefit of Greek-speaking Jews) rendered “Qohelet” as “Ekklesiastes.” This later became the Latin “Ecclesiastes.”

The word has nothing to do with any church. The word “ecclesia” came to be used for a church only centuries after Ecclesiastes was written.

By the way, in Hebrew both the book and its speaker are named “Qohelet.” To keep matters straight, scholars often use “Qohelet” to refer to the person, “Ecclesiastes” to the book.


When was it written?

No one knows for sure. As with nearly everything else about Ecclesiastes, opinions differ. For those who think the author was Solomon, the book would have been written roughly three thousand years ago, in the tenth century BCE. Give or take a century, most modern scholars date it to about the third century BCE.


Where was it written?

Most likely somewhere in Palestine, perhaps Jerusalem.


What language is it written in?

Hebrew. Some scholars have proposed that the Hebrew text is a translation from some other language, like Aramaic, but such notions have failed to win much acceptance.


What is the book about?

The book begins with a powerfully expressed argument that our life on earth is pointless, that we spend it working hard for vanity, for nothing better than vapor, and then die and disappear into oblivion. Still, human beings should enjoy the limited pleasures life affords, since there is nothing better. In the course of the book, Qohelet speaks of many topics, but keeps returning to these themes.


How did Ecclesiastes get into the Bible?

Good question. Even Jewish rabbis have sometimes wondered how such an unusual book entered their scriptural canon. One answer is that the book was long attributed to the great and wise King Solomon. Another answer is that an epilogue wraps the book up with a pious and orthodox ending. A third answer some scholars give is that the forming of the Hebrew canon was determined not by a series of councils but by a historical process that stretched over centuries. Certain books that were a party of the literary heritage of the Hebrew people – in the words of one scholar, “a national literature upon a religious foundation” – gradually came to be thought of as scripture. And Ecclesiastes was a book of such searching thought and powerful expression that it had to be a book to keep. How it could be considered sacred was later debated, but by that time the book was already in.

Resources
  • Ecclesiastes
    • FAQ
    • Ecclesiastes — the full English text
  • Krishna Spirituality
  • Video
  • Images
  • Audio
    • Pronunciation
      • Hebrew
        • How do I say…
      • Sanskrit
        • How do I say…
        • How to pronounce the Sanskrit letters
        • Verses Quoted
    • Readings of Ecclesiastes
      • Ecclesiastes read in English
      • Ecclesiastes read in Hebrew
    • Music
      • Turn! Turn! Turn!
      • Ecclesiastes music: classical and contemporary
      • “There’s a Great Big Beautiful Tomorrow”

Sign Up for the Mailing List

Follow

logo-facebook
  • Contact
  • |
  • Back to top

© 2025 Bhaktivedanta Book Trust International